Someone says there are twice as many hikers, then says trip reports are to blame for there being twice as many people at certain places. Ridiculous on its face.
You may be referring to my comments since I noted that there are now more than twice as many hikers. If you indeed are referring to my comments, you are doing a bad hatchet job of a strawman with how you have reframed what I wrote. In fact I commented that I don't know how much the traffic on this route has increased and have seen no evidence anyone else knows this either. And I also noted that I haven't seen many TR's anywhere on this route (though I've seen a few over time). All I noted was that of course online trip reports have an influence on where people go (and I'll add here that some places have seen far more than a doubling or tripling of traffic), as was the case for me in choosing how to approach my own trips in this area. If you've never taken a cue on where to go base on reading trip reports you may not see this from your own personal experience and thus not quite see it as obviously but I've also talked to many others (including to people who were parts of crowds that had suddenly appeared on routes that were previously quiet, who responded to my friendly queries that they'd chosen the route based on having read - you guessed it - trip reports) and for sure it has an influence.
For the record, I'll re-state what I noted above - from what I know of Ann Nelson, I don't think she was suckered into something over her head in doing this route. She's done several much more technical routes quite successfully. I'll also add that I don't know anything about this unfortunate man who also died on this route. Nothing I wrote was intended to suggest that he was lured in over his head by social media. There were one or two suggestions along these lines above my comments which I tried to counter with my first post. I think it's quite possible for these two things to be true: that social media is having a big impact on where people go; and that these tragedies may have little or nothing to do with the influence of social media.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum You cannot attach files in this forum You can download files in this forum